Talkie vs Character AI: Voice-First Fun or Long-Form Roleplay?
Two very different companion apps: Talkie sells short, voiced chats with card packs, while Character AI sells long stories with memory tools....
Chub AI gave roleplayers a huge card library and their own API keys. Then came the Australia block, the $20 model tier and the rough edges. Here is where to go next, matched to why you are leaving.
Chub AI is an odd hybrid: a character card archive bolted onto a chat front end. It formed in 2024 from a merger of the CharacterHub card site and the Venus front end, and it kept both halves. You get a large library of characters and lorebooks, browser chat, and the option to plug in your own API key from OpenAI, Anthropic, Google, OpenRouter, Kobold or Ooba.
Every character on Chub is rated SFW or NSFW, and tags do the filtering. That structure is why people stay. It is also why leaving is annoying: your cards, your lorebooks and your chat history live inside someone else's website.
There is no single best replacement. There are three different exits, and the right one depends on what pushed you out the door.
Chub withdrew from Australia in late 2025. The eSafety Commissioner issued a legal notice dated October 16, 2025, and Chub geoblocked the country. A moderator confirmed the block on Reddit, and the Digital Policy Alert recorded the company's statement. Interim findings from eSafety on Chub were published March 23, 2026.
A VPN may get you back in, but dodging a geoblock can break the site's terms. If you want a legal route, you need a platform that accepts Australian users. Watch for age checks: JanitorAI runs one for Australia, Brazil and the UK, and Character AI may ask adults for a selfie or ID.
Chub's own docs put the Mars plan at $20/month with unlimited messages. Mars subscribers get Soji, a 671B DeepSeek V3 fine-tune with a 60K context window. Third-party reviews list a Mercury plan at roughly $5/month, but that tier runs smaller models.
So the cheap plan and the good plan are different products. If your complaint is "I am paying $20 for one model," the fix is usually software that lets you buy model access directly. You will pay per token instead of per month, which is cheaper for light use and more expensive if you chat for hours every night.
Reviewers describe Chub as a hobbyist lab: desktop-first, occasionally unstable. The free tier gives basic model access, and users report the usual symptoms of a small model, namely looping and personality drift. If you want a polished app that just works on your phone, Chub was never that.
| Alternative | Best for | Price from | Free tier | Card files |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| SillyTavern | Power users, any model | Free software; pay model | Yes | Yes, imports Chub |
| RisuAI | Bring-your-own-key chats | Free software; pay model | Yes | Yes |
| JanitorAI | Hosted with optional API key | $0; Janitor+ $12.99/month | Yes | No, rebuild |
| SpicyChat | Huge updated bot library | $5.95/month | Yes, with queue | No, rebuild |
| CrushOn AI | Polished Chub-style hosted | $5.99/month | Limited messages | No |
| Backyard AI | Privacy and local models | Cloud plans extra | Yes | Own hub |
| PolyBuzz | Chat with built-in images | $9.90/month | Yes, with ads | No |
| Character AI | Safe casual roleplay | $9.99/month c.ai+ | Yes, with ads | No |
We did not test these platforms. Rankings here rest on published features, pricing pages, policies and what users report. Three things decide whether an alternative actually replaces Chub for you:
Prices below were checked in early October 2026. No platform paid for a listing.
SillyTavern is free open-source software that runs on your machine. It imports Chub cards directly, so your library survives the move. You pay for model access separately, either through an API key or a local model.
The cost is time. Setup takes an afternoon, and if you expose it to the internet you need a password. But it gives you what Chub gave you: your cards, your lorebooks, and the model of your choice. For most ex-Chub users, this is the answer.
RisuAI is also open-source and free. It supports OpenAI, Claude, Gemini, OpenRouter and local models. It runs at risuai.net, as a desktop app, or self-hosted, and its card hub is called RisuRealm. Features include emotion images, lorebooks and memory tools.
The trade-off is the same as SillyTavern: quality depends on the model you plug in, and the API bill is yours. If you want local control without a terminal, this is the gentler option.
JanitorAI is free with JanitorLLM, and it accepts external API keys or proxies. Janitor+ costs $12.99/month, a price that has applied since June 2026, and gives roughly five times the context.
Two catches. It runs an age check for users in Australia, Brazil and the UK. And it has no images, voice or video, and no Chub card upload, so you rebuild characters by copying fields. If you want a hosted, free, text-first home, it is the obvious first stop.
SpicyChat counts more than 138,000 community characters by the company's own tally. Tiers rose on September 8, 2026 to $5.95, $19.95 and $29.95 monthly. Paid tiers add memory, speed, in-chat images and the SpicyXL model. Free users queue at busy times.
Community reports say lower tiers lose the thread after 15 to 20 messages. That is the cheap-monthly-price trap in miniature: you are not paying for memory at $5.95.
CrushOn AI is the closest thing to a Chub-style experience without setup. No API key, and you get group chat, custom voices and images. Explicit chat starts at the Standard tier of $5.99/month, with a ladder that runs to $199.99.
The free tier is a short trial, and the best memory sits on the expensive tiers. For a full comparison of hosted roleplay apps and what they cost, see our guide to the best AI chatbot for roleplay.
Backyard AI is a desktop app that runs models on your own machine, which is the strongest privacy story on this list. The catch: in February 2025 the team said the desktop app would get no new features, and the homepage now leads with iOS/Android apps and cloud plans. Local models also need a decent graphics card.
PolyBuzz pairs chat with built-in image generation and reports more than 20 million user-made characters. The free version has ads; paid starts at $9.90/month plus coins. It filters adult content, so it is not a like-for-like NSFW swap for Chub.
Character AI has a large customizable library, a clean UI, and video and voice. It added conversation images in August 2025, and c.ai+ costs $9.99/month. But it bans NSFW, and it banned open-ended chat for under-18s in November 2025. It may ask adults for a selfie or ID. If you are leaving Chub for a tamer product, it fits. If you are leaving for more control, it does not.
| Platform | Plan | Price |
|---|---|---|
| Chub AI | Mars | $20/month |
| Chub AI | Mercury (third-party) | about $5/month |
| JanitorAI | Janitor+ | $12.99/month |
| SpicyChat | Tiers | $5.95 / $19.95 / $29.95 monthly |
| CrushOn AI | Standard to top | $5.99 to $199.99/month |
| PolyBuzz | Paid | from $9.90/month plus coins |
| Character AI | c.ai+ | $9.99/month |
| Kindroid | Paid | from $15.99/month |
| Sakura.fm | Paid | from $19/month |
| Secrets AI | Premium | $19.99/month |
Some people leaving Chub do not want another card site. They want an app that remembers them. That is a different market, and the prices reflect it.
Secrets AI offers model choice, editable Lorebooks on the Ultimate tier, voice, images and short video. Premium is $19.99/month. We rate Secrets AI 9.9 out of 10; our Secrets AI review covers where the bills creep up.
Kindroid has persistent identity, layered memory, voice calls, selfies and video, from $15.99/month. Sakura.fm, per a smartpostly review, is built for long mobile sessions, with plans from $19/month. Yodayo bundles image generation with voice, music and video, and moderation runs from PG to XXX per DreamGen. DreamGen also notes Yodayo includes 150 generated images per month. TalkieMate claims lifelike NSFW conversations, but that claim is unverified.
For the companion side, Candy.ai and OurDream AI are the two we get asked about most. We rate Candy.ai 9.8 out of 10 and OurDream AI 9.7 out of 10. Both are subscriptions with media meters, not card archives. If you are weighing them, our Candy AI alternatives guide maps complaints to fixes.
Chub's library is the hard part to replace. A few smaller sites help:
SillyTavern can also import JanitorAI links through JannyAI, which makes it a bridge between the two ecosystems.
Do this before you cancel anything.
Long chats rarely import cleanly. A summary restores most of the context, so write one before you go.
On any hosted platform, assume staff can read your chats. Check the training and deletion policy before you paste anything personal. Using your own API key does not make you invisible either: your conversations still go to the model provider.
There is precedent for taking this seriously. A 2024 breach at Muah.ai exposed about 1.9 million email addresses plus prompts. Prompts are the intimate part.
Every site here is adults only, and every legitimate platform bans minor content. Skip any card library that does not make every character an adult.
Test two or three for a week before you commit, and pay monthly. If a cheap tier hides a memory cap or a token meter, you will find out fast.
Chub AI is still strong for portable cards, bots and model choice. The Australia block, the $20 best-model tier and the uneven quality are what push people out. If you are leaving, download your cards first. Then decide whether you want software you control or a hosted site that runs itself. Most ex-Chub users end up happier with the former.
For most ex-Chub users, SillyTavern: it imports Chub cards and lets you use any model, though setup takes an afternoon and you pay model costs separately. If you want no install, JanitorAI, SpicyChat and CrushOn AI are the hosted options.
The eSafety Commissioner issued a legal notice dated October 16, 2025, and Chub geoblocked Australia in late 2025. A moderator confirmed the block on Reddit, and interim findings were published March 23, 2026. VPN workarounds may break the site's terms, so a legal alternative is the safer route.
Yes. JanitorAI is free with JanitorLLM, and SpicyChat has a free tier with a queue at busy times. SillyTavern and RisuAI are free software, but you pay for the model you connect to them.
Yes, in SillyTavern and RisuAI. Download the card, usually a PNG with embedded JSON in V2 or V3 format, and import it. Hosted sites like JanitorAI, SpicyChat and CrushOn AI have no Chub card upload, so you rebuild characters by copying fields.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls