Talkie vs Character AI: Voice-First Fun or Long-Form Roleplay?
Two very different companion apps: Talkie sells short, voiced chats with card packs, while Character AI sells long stories with memory tools....
Dippy is a decent free start, but people leave for specific reasons: ads, patchy memory, vague premium pricing. Here's a replacement for each of those complaints, with prices and caveats.
Dippy is a free AI chat and roleplay app on iOS, Android and the web. People praise its character writing: each character keeps its own personality, and it shows. But the free tier runs on unlimited messages plus frequent ads and subscription prompts, and premium pricing shifts by store and region. Users report memory lapses in longer conversations, repetitive replies and the occasional bug.
If you're leaving, the useful question isn't "what's the best AI girlfriend app?" It's "what annoyed me most?" The answer changes the pick. Below, each section starts with the complaint and ends with the app that fixes it, plus the catch. No app paid to be here.
| Reason | Best pick | Entry price USD | Adult content |
|---|---|---|---|
| Ads and upsells | Janitor AI | Free; Janitor+ $12.99/month | Yes |
| Ads plus privacy | SillyTavern | Free (pay for API) | Depends on model |
| Private local chat | HammerAI | Free with local models | Uncensored mode (reported) |
| Inconsistent memory | Nomi | $15.99/month (App Store) | Explicit text only |
| Memory plus calls | Kindroid | $15.99/month (App Store) | Adults only |
| One supportive companion | Replika | Varies by store | Limited |
| Bigger library | Character AI | Free; c.ai+ $9.99/month | No |
| More control | Chub | Free; Mars $20/month | Yes, rated cards |
| Content limits, budget | SpicyChat | Free; paid from $5.95 | Yes |
| Content limits, models | CrushOn AI | Free; paid from $5.99 | Filter switch |
| Stories not chat | AI Dungeon, NovelAI, DreamGen | Free tier / from $10 / from $7.83 | Settings vary |
| Realistic pictures | Candy.ai | $3.99/month billed yearly | Adults only |
| Memory and calls | Secrets AI | $9.17/month billed yearly | Adults only |
| Image volume | OurDream AI | $9.99/month billed yearly | Adults only |
People lump Dippy in with Character AI because both are free, hosted, and built around chatting with other people's characters. The differences matter more than the similarities.
Character AI has the bigger library and unlimited free messaging, plus free Character Voice for everyone and Character Calls on the web. But its filter is strict. A 2026 community survey found 73% of respondents said the filter broke non-sexual creative work at least once per session. In November 2025, under-18 accounts lost open-ended chats, and age checks now run through Persona. Free users also report full-screen ads. c.ai+ runs $9.99/month or $94.99/year for quicker replies and fewer ads.
Janitor AI takes the other road: a hosted library the help pages put at over 1.4 million public characters, JanitorLLM included free, and adult roleplay allowed for verified adults within the rules. No calls, no image generation.
Dippy sits between them. It's praised for natural character writing and 18+ rated by the App Store for crude humor and suggestive content, but reports on its filter conflict: one source says fewer filters, others cite free-tier limits. If filter uncertainty is your complaint, test Janitor AI or SpicyChat before paying anyone.
Each maps to a different fix. That's the whole structure of this piece.
We didn't test these apps. Our rankings come from published features, pricing pages, policies and what users report. We checked entry prices, what each tier includes, refund and cancellation terms, and the known complaints. Where a vendor makes a claim, we attribute it. Where information conflicts, we say so.
One more thing: no Dippy export tool turned up. If you want to move a character, copy the personality, persona, style and backstory by hand, then test it in a short chat before you commit. And cancel Dippy in the store you subscribed through before you delete the app, or the subscription may keep billing.
If the ads pushed you out, pick a free tier that doesn't interrupt the chat.
Janitor AI is the hosted pick. Free with JanitorLLM included, or bring your own API key for an external model. Janitor+ is $12.99/month, or $8.25/month billed yearly, and adds priority messaging, 5x context and 300 enhanced swipes monthly. The library is huge. The catches: after an April 2026 model swap, users complained, and the default model is only fair; there are no calls or image generation.
SillyTavern is the privacy pick. Free, open-source under AGPL-3.0, self-hosted. It connects to OpenRouter, OpenAI, Anthropic or a local KoboldAI backend. You get World Info lore, group chats, persona, TTS and Stable Diffusion extensions, and your chats and character cards stay on your machine. The catch is setup time, API costs are yours, and the big labs disallow explicit content through their APIs.
For more free-tier options, see our AI girlfriend reviews hub.
Memory is the most common reason people switch, and the most expensive to fix properly.
Nomi is built around it: layered short, medium and long-term memory plus a Mind Map. Standard is $15.99/month or $99.99/year per the App Store. It allows explicit text for adults, though nude photos are not allowed. Watch out: a paid Anchors update from April 2026 irritated veteran users, and the free tier is small.
Kindroid stacks memory systems on top of custom traits, backstory, key memories, example messages and a response directive. Group chats, calls and cloning are included. It's $15.99/month on the App Store. The caveats are real: the free Lite plan ended October 1, 2026, newcomers get a 50-message preview then read-only chats, and every call minute burns credits.
Secrets AI is the adult-focused option, with layered memory, Lorebooks and real-time calls with the same character. It's $19.99/month, or $109.99/year (about $9.17/month), and the yearly plan includes 8,000 Moments of credit. Personas and group chats require the $39.99 Ultimate tier, free accounts get 20 messages daily, and unused Moments expire monthly. We rate Secrets AI 9.9 overall; read the full Secrets AI review before you pay.
Character AI remains the biggest free library, and you can build your own characters. Conversation images arrived in August 2025 according to a DreamGen review. The catch is the filter and the ads, both covered above.
Chub formed when CharacterHub and Venus merged in 2024. It's free with your own OpenAI, Anthropic, Google or OpenRouter keys, or $20/month on the Mars plan for unlimited use of your own models including a 60K-context model. Rated cards are allowed. The catch: Chub blocks Australian users after a regulator notice, and the interface has rough edges.
Dippy's filter reports conflict. If you hit a wall, these apps allow adult roleplay for verified adults within their rules.
SpicyChat tiers after a September 2026 increase: $5.95, $19.95 and $29.95 monthly. Free chat sometimes queues at peak times. The top tier adds larger memory, more models and text to speech. Cheaper tiers have short context, and there's no native iPhone app.
CrushOn AI has Filtered and Unfiltered modes, more than 20 AI models, audio messages and custom voice cloning. Free accounts get 100 message credits monthly plus unlimited free-model chats. Standard starts at $5.99/month, but prices climb to $199.99/month at the top, and free accounts lose chat history after seven days without login. Group chat is paid only.
For a closer look at how filters and pictures trade off, see CrushOn AI vs Candy AI.
Some Dippy users are really writing stories. Chat apps frustrate them.
Candy.ai is the picture pick: photorealistic images, image-to-video clips, audio notes and a detailed builder. It's $3.99/month billed yearly, or $13.99 monthly. The yearly plan includes unlimited chat plus 100 monthly tokens. Here's the trap: each image costs about 4 tokens, and heavy users report spending $25 to $80 monthly. Long-term memory is weak, and the refund window is 24 hours. We rate Candy.ai 9.8; the Candy.ai review lays out the token math.
Secrets AI covers memory plus live calls with the same character. OurDream AI covers image volume: $9.99/month billed yearly for unlimited chat and 1,000 dreamcoins (about 200 images), plus voice calls, realistic and anime styles, and group roleplay. Older plot details may slip, and lapsing your plan blurs your creations. We rate OurDream AI 9.7; see the OurDream AI review.
If you want to compare the three directly, start with Best AI Girlfriend Apps, Ranked by What They Cost and What They Remember.
| App | Group chats | Voice | Image generation | Model access |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Janitor AI | No | No | No | House model or own API |
| SillyTavern | Yes | TTS extension | Via extension | Any API or local model |
| Nomi | Yes (paid) | Calls | Yes | House models |
| Kindroid | Yes | Calls, cloning | Selfies | House models |
| Character AI | Yes | Free voice, calls | Reported | House models |
| Chub AI | Not confirmed | Reported | Yes | House models or own keys |
| CrushOn AI | Paid plans | Audio messages | Yes | 20+ models |
| Secrets AI | Ultimate | Live calls | Yes | House models |
Free tiers buy you access. Paid tiers buy you memory, media, speed or fewer interruptions.
One pattern repeats: a cheap monthly price can hide a token meter. Candy's $3.99 yearly rate looks great until you count images at about 4 tokens each. Secrets' annual plan includes 8,000 Moments, but unused Moments expire monthly. OurDream bundles 1,000 dreamcoins, roughly 200 images, and blurs your creations if you lapse. Budget by what you'll actually use, not by the sticker.
Hosted services store chats on their servers. Only local setups like SillyTavern or HammerAI's local mode keep chats on your device. If you use an API key, set a spending cap and never share the key.
Age checks matter too: Character AI runs them through Persona, and adult content is restricted to verified adults on the platforms that allow it. Botify's underage celebrity bot episode is a reminder that character libraries need moderation. Set time limits for yourself. Companion apps are not a substitute for friends or professional help.
Try two apps for a week each. Pay only for the keeper. Our scores change as prices and policies do, which is why we write them like Candy.ai 9.8 rather than freezing a number in the text. For more replacement routes, see 10 Candy AI Alternatives.
Dippy is a fine free start, but users outgrow the ads, the unclear premium pricing and the patchy memory. The fix depends on the complaint. Pick by problem, test two apps, and pay only when one earns it.
Janitor AI is the strongest hosted free option: no message cap, a huge public character library and adult roleplay for verified adults. SillyTavern is free too, but you host it yourself and pay for the model API. Character AI is free as well, though its filter is stricter.
Nomi and Kindroid are built around persistent memory systems, and Secrets AI is the adult-focused pick with layered memory and Lorebooks. All three charge for it: Nomi and Kindroid are $15.99/month on the App Store, and Secrets AI starts around $9.17/month billed yearly.
Janitor AI, SpicyChat, CrushOn AI and Chub allow adult roleplay for verified adults within their rules. Filter strength and enforcement vary by app, and reports on some filters conflict, so test before paying for a year.
No Dippy export tool turned up in our research. You can copy a character's personality, persona, style and backstory by hand, then test it in a short chat before committing to a subscription.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls