Talkie vs Character AI: Voice-First Fun or Long-Form Roleplay?
Two very different companion apps: Talkie sells short, voiced chats with card packs, while Character AI sells long stories with memory tools....
Nastia AI is cheap and warm until the memory slips or the token meter bites. Here are ten alternatives, each picked for a specific reason you might be leaving.
You are paying for Nastia AI or testing it, and something is off. Maybe your companion forgot a detail you told it last week. Maybe the images burned through your tokens faster than you expected. Maybe you just want live voice calls, not voice notes. The right replacement depends on which of those complaints is yours.
Nastia has real strengths: chat is cheap, the tone is warm, and the Unlimited plan at $15.99/month is good value if you mostly text. But memory fades, media costs extra, and the pricing page has some contradictions worth knowing before you switch. This guide starts from your complaint, not a single winner.
If you only read one table, read this one. Each row starts with the thing that broke and names the app that fixes it.
| Leaving because | Try | Paid from | Free tier |
|---|---|---|---|
| Companion forgets | Secrets AI | $9.17/month annual | 20 messages daily |
| Stable long-term recall | Nomi AI | $8.33/month annual | Limited messages |
| Customization and calls | Kindroid | $13.33/month annual App Store | One-time preview |
| Stylized images | Candy AI | $3.99/month annual | 5 messages |
| Image and video volume | OurDream AI | $9.99/month annual | Limited, no images |
| Huge bot library | SpicyChat | $5.95/month | Yes, with queue |
| Tokens and free roleplay | Janitor AI | Free; $12.99 Janitor+ | Yes |
| Cheap unfiltered tiers | CrushOn AI | $5.99/month | 100 credits monthly |
| SFW character app | Character AI | $9.99/month c.ai+ | Unlimited with ads |
| Gentle SFW friend | Replika AI | $5.83/month annual App Store | Basic friend chat |
We rate Candy.ai 9.8 out of 10 overall, and its pictures carry the score. Secrets AI scores 9.9 with memory as the strong suit. Neither is a universal answer, which is why the rest of this page walks through each complaint.
Nastia recalls over 50 messages, according to its own materials, but reviewers say details last about two weeks. One reviewer found a detail present on day four and gone by day seven. That is the core memory complaint: it works for a fling, not a long storyline.
Pricing is the second issue. Nastia lists a free tier and paid plans at $11.99 and $15.99 monthly. But one comparison site still quotes $6.69/month, and older listings showed a $6.69 Standard tier. If you signed up expecting that, the current checkout will surprise you. The free tier is called free forever on one page, while the pricing card lists daily token limits.
Media is the third. Images and voice notes consume tokens, and even Unlimited hits media limits. Voice is messages and cloning on Unlimited; we found no live calls on the official pages. Group chats hold up to 10 companions, which is generous for scene-building but doesn't solve memory or media costs.
Nastia still has a case for staying: cheap, warm, uncensored chat and group scenes. If that's all you want, the $15.99 Unlimited plan remains good value for chat alone. The alternatives below matter when you want something Nastia doesn't do well.
We looked at published pricing, feature pages, policies, and what users report. Four criteria did most of the work:
We did not run test accounts or buy subscriptions. Everything here comes from published information and user reports. Prices move often in this niche; confirm at checkout.
Secrets AI is the closest thing to a direct upgrade for most Nastia users. The free tier gives 20 messages daily plus basic memory, which is enough to see whether the tone suits you. Premium is $19.99/month or $109.99/year, about $9.17/month. That buys unlimited messages, premium memory, video, and 8,000 Moments monthly.
Ultimate at $39.99/month adds Lorebooks, personas, proactive messages, and 2-3 companion group chats. Voice calls cost 50 Moments per minute; images cost 50 Moments each. Extra custom characters cost 500 Moments, with the first free.
The caveats matter. Lorebooks are Ultimate-only. Moments do not roll over. And the policy says chats may be used to train models. If memory is your complaint, this is the app to beat; our Secrets AI review goes deeper on the billing side.
Comparison sites cite Nomi as having the best long-term memory in the category. It uses short-, medium-, and long-term memory plus a Mind Map. Paid accounts keep 10 active Nomis and 10 active group conversations.
App Store pricing is $15.99/month, $39.99/quarter, or $99.99/year, about $8.33/month. A cheaper Launch Plan is listed, but availability is unclear. The free plan gives limited daily text messages.
Nomi allows adult text roleplay but no nude photos, per its own docs. That conflicts with some third-party claims that Nomi is fully SFW. Other caveats: small free allowance and no end-to-end encryption.
Kindroid's builder asks for backstory, key memories, sample dialogue, and a response directive. That is more setup than Nastia, and it pays off if you want control. Kindroid documents five memory systems, which review sites call five-layer. It also offers proactive messages, voice cloning, real-time voice calls, live video calls, selfies, group chats, and texting via iMessage or RCS.
Pricing is messy. One list says the only paid plan is $11.66/month. The App Store lists Standard at $15.99/month or $159.99/year, about $13.33/month, with optional Ultra and MAX add-ons and a lower web price reported. The Lite free tier retired October 1, 2026; new sign-ups get a one-off allowance around 50 messages, then read-only.
Caveats: the free preview is short, calls burn audio credits, and add-ons get expensive.
Candy's builder covers looks, age, body type, hair, voice, hobbies, and personality. Tokens pay for images, voice, video, and custom characters. Premium adds unlimited text, voice messages, beta voice calls, 18+ images, and image-to-video.
The headline price is $13.99/month or about $3.99/month annual. The catch: Premium bundles only 100 media tokens monthly, and heavy media users report monthly bills of $25 to $80. The free plan is five messages. Testers also report storylines reset after a few days, and Premium Plus has 20 memory slots.
If you want pictures and can budget for tokens, Candy is strong. If you want memory, look elsewhere; our Candy.ai review explains why.
OurDream Premium is $19.99/month or $9.99/month yearly. It bundles unlimited messages plus 1,000 monthly dreamcoins, which buys about 200 images or 10 short video clips. Live calls bill at 50 coins per minute. Free users spend a coin per chat message and get no image or video generation.
Caveats: recall relies on the latest messages, training on chats is allowed, and the homepage encryption claim differs from the policy. If you want volume media, it is a better deal than Nastia's token meter; our OurDream AI review covers the billing details.
SpicyChat tiers are now $5.95, $19.95, and $29.95 monthly; prices rose September 8, 2026. Paid tiers unlock larger memory, better models, text-to-speech, and conversation images. Annual is about 17% off.
Caveats: the free queue is slow and memory is short, there is no iOS app, and support complaints are frequent. If you want a large library and cheap entry, it works; if you want polish, keep reading.
Janitor AI is free with its own JanitorLLM model and supports bring-your-own API key. Janitor+ is $12.99/month or about $8.25/month yearly, giving a 5x context window, priority replies, and 300 enhanced swipes monthly.
Caveats: no images, no voice, variable free-model uptime, and an API learning curve. The bring-your-own-key route is the DIY adult option; OpenAI and Gemini APIs restrict sexual content, so choose your provider carefully.
CrushOn free accounts get 100 message credits monthly, and free models are uncapped. Standard is $5.99/month, Premium $14.99/month, and the ladder climbs steeply. Memory ranges from 8K to 24K context by plan. Annual starts at $4.90.
NSFW depends on content switches and an age check. Caveat: idle free accounts lose chat history after seven days.
Character AI has millions of user-generated characters, widely reported. Free messaging is unlimited with ads, and NSFW limits are strict. c.ai+ costs $9.99/month or $94.99/year, removing waiting rooms and ads.
Caveats: no adult roleplay, free ads, and memory resets in long chats. If you want SFW character play, it is the biggest sandbox; if you want adult content, it is the wrong door.
Replika's free tier covers basic friend chat; Pro adds romantic mode, voice calls, and selfies. It uses XP, levels, and coins in gamified progression. App Store pricing is $7.99 or $14.99 monthly, or $5.83/month annual. One comparison site says nearly $20/month; $19.99 is widely repeated, so check in-app.
Caveats: strict NSFW filters, prices only in-app, and Italy fined the developer EUR 5 million under GDPR. Replika pulled erotic roleplay in February 2023 and restored it for some older accounts a month later.
Some apps appear in lists but lack enough independent data for a full review. Kissable directories claim a knowledge graph for persistent memory. Kalon's maker says customization plus ongoing conversations and memory. SoulFun is described in one list as having a video generator and image generation with aggressive NSFW moderation. Crushi uses a Trust Level XP system and is priced at $7.99/week, about $32/month. Anima reviewers report a yearly plan at $39.99, about $3.33/month, mostly text. Treat these as leads, not endorsements.
Monthly prices hide token meters. The annual column is where the deals are, but check what media is included before you commit.
| App | Monthly | Annual per month | Free tier | Media paid with |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Nastia AI | $11.99 / $15.99 | About $8.33 reported | Daily token limits | Tokens |
| Secrets AI | $19.99 | $9.17 | 20 messages daily | Moments |
| Nomi AI | $15.99 | $8.33 | Limited messages | Credits |
| Kindroid | $15.99 App Store | $13.33 | One-time preview | Credits |
| Candy AI | $13.99 | $3.99 | 5 messages | Tokens |
| OurDream AI | $19.99 | $9.99 | Pay-per-message coins | Dreamcoins |
| SpicyChat | $5.95 to $29.95 | About 17% off | Yes, with queue | Included by tier |
| Janitor AI | $12.99 optional | $8.25 | Full platform | No media |
| CrushOn AI | $5.99 and up | From $4.90 | 100 credits monthly | Credits |
| Character AI | $9.99 | $7.92 | Unlimited with ads | Charms |
| Replika AI | $7.99 or $14.99 App Store | $5.83 | Basic friend chat | Gems |
Two pricing traps run through this table. First, a low monthly price often hides a token meter: Candy at $3.99/month annual still bundles only 100 media tokens, and Nastia's Unlimited still hits media limits. Second, figures conflict across sources. Kindroid's $11.66 claim conflicts with the $15.99 App Store price. Replika's $19.99 figure conflicts with App Store $7.99 and $14.99. Treat any number you see in a roundup, including this one, as a starting point.
Memory is where Nastia users complain most, and where the alternatives differ most in approach.
Secrets AI sells premium memory on Premium and lets Ultimate users edit memory directly. Nomi uses layered memory plus a Mind Map and is repeatedly cited for recall. Kindroid documents five memory systems and asks you to write key memories at setup. Candy's storylines reset after a few days for testers; Premium Plus adds 20 memory slots. OurDream's recall relies on the latest messages. Janitor+ gives 5x the context window. CrushOn ranges from 8K to 24K context by plan. Character AI resets memory in long chats.
If you want to compare writing quality in more depth, our guide to the best AI chatbot for roleplay covers what writes well and what remembers.
These two get compared often, and the comparison is lopsided. Nastia allows adult content; Replika does not, and its filters are strict. Nastia's comparison page claims Replika remembers only 10 messages; that is an unverified competitor claim, so don't take it as fact.
One comparison site rates Nastia and Replika both 5.0/5.0 in customization, which tells you less than the content rules do. If you want a gentle SFW friend with gamified progression, Replika is fine. If you want adult chat, Nastia already does that, and switching to Replika would be a downgrade on that axis.
Janitor AI supports bring-your-own API key, which is the closest thing to a DIY companion. You pick the model and pay the provider directly. The catch is that OpenAI and Gemini APIs restrict sexual content, so adult roleplay depends on choosing a provider that permits it. There is a learning curve, and uptime varies by provider, but it gives you control no subscription app offers.
No app here verifiably offers end-to-end encryption. Secrets' policy cites AES-256 for stored data; Kindroid encrypts stored and transmitted data; Nastia describes encryption in transit only. Nomi, Kindroid, and Replika lack end-to-end encryption.
Training policies vary. Secrets and OurDream may train models on chats. CrushOn wipes idle free accounts after seven days. Nastia requires canceling your subscription before account deletion, and its terms ban minors content including aged-up characters and real-person impersonation.
Read the policy before you share anything identifying. And keep perspective: AI companionship is not a substitute for a therapist.
Test the free tier first in every case. The free tier tells you more about fit than any table.
There is no single Nastia AI alternative, because there is no single reason people leave. If memory is the complaint, Secrets AI, Nomi, and Kindroid are the serious answers. If media is the complaint, Candy and OurDream beat Nastia's token meter. If price or free access is the complaint, SpicyChat, Janitor, and CrushOn are cheaper doors. And if chat is all you want, Nastia's Unlimited plan is still good value.
Start from your complaint, test the free tier, and confirm the price at checkout. That is the whole method.
Secrets AI is the best all-round replacement for memory, calls, images, and adult content. OurDream and Candy are better if images or price matter most. There is no single winner; match the app to your complaint.
Janitor AI is free for text, SpicyChat is free with a queue, CrushOn gives 100 credits monthly, Character AI is unlimited with ads but SFW, and Secrets gives 20 messages daily. Free tiers are the cheapest way to test fit.
Secrets AI, Nomi AI, and Kindroid are the memory leaders. Secrets Ultimate lets you edit memory, Nomi is praised for recall, and Kindroid documents five memory systems.
Secrets, Candy, OurDream, SpicyChat, Janitor, CrushOn, and Kindroid allow adult content for verified adults. Nomi allows adult text but no nudes; Character AI and free Replika do not allow NSFW.
Secrets, Kindroid, and OurDream offer live calls; Candy has beta calls; Replika Pro has calls. Nastia offers only voice messages, not live calls, on its official pages.
Yes, for cheap warm uncensored chat and group scenes. The $15.99 Unlimited plan is good value for chat. It is weaker on memory, media, and pricing clarity.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls