Talkie vs Character AI: Voice-First Fun or Long-Form Roleplay?
Two very different companion apps: Talkie sells short, voiced chats with card packs, while Character AI sells long stories with memory tools....
Nastia AI sells conversation and a usable free tier. Candy AI sells the best-looking images in the category. The right pick depends on whether you want a pen pal or a photoshoot.
Nastia AI and Candy AI get compared a lot, partly because Nastia's own site runs a page arguing Candy is a token trap. That page is a vendor argument, not a review. So here is the neutral version: one platform is built around ongoing chat, the other around photorealistic pictures and short video. Your pick depends on which of those you actually open the app for.
We have not tested either platform hands-on. Everything below comes from published pricing pages, terms, privacy policies and user reports. Prices and policies change, so check before you pay.
| Category | Nastia AI | Candy AI | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Ongoing chat, roleplay, companionship | Photorealistic images and short videos | Depends on you |
| Monthly price | $11.99 or $15.99 Unlimited | $13.99, or $3.99/month billed yearly | Candy yearly |
| Free version | Yes, daily token limits | 5 messages total, 1 character, 1 image | Nastia |
| Memory | Advertised persistent; reviewers report gaps | Reportedly resets after 48โ72 hours | Nastia slightly |
| Images/video | Stylized, 1080p video on Unlimited | Most realistic, image-to-video, Live Action mode | Candy |
| Voice | Messages plus custom voice cloning | Messages plus beta voice calls | Candy |
| Group chats | Up to 10 companions | Not documented | Nastia |
| Company | Nastia Cybernetics, registered in France | EverAI Limited, Malta | Both EU |
| Watch out | Contradictory free-tier wording, token-metered media | 100 tokens monthly, strict refunds | โ |
If the answer has to be one line: Nastia is the better chat app, Candy is the better camera. Neither is good at remembering you for months, and neither offers end-to-end encryption.
Nastia is run by Nastia Cybernetics, registered in France. Ahrefs puts its monthly organic traffic at roughly 548,000 visits, ahead of Candy's roughly 332,000. Nastia advertises 800,000+ users; that is a company figure we cannot verify.
The pitch is flat pricing and no token traps. The reality is more nuanced: the Unlimited plan means unlimited messages, and media still costs tokens. We rate Nastia 9.4 out of 10 overall. Its chat experience lands around 8/10 in at least one published review, which matches the general user mood: decent conversation, weak visuals.
Candy is run by EverAI Limited, registered in Malta. It is the platform people name when they want an image that looks like a photograph rather than a rendering. Premium unlocks unlimited messages and 18+ images and video, but comes with 100 tokens a month. We rate Candy.ai 9.8 out of 10. For the full breakdown of its strengths and limits, read our Candy.ai review.
Both companies sit in the EU, which matters for privacy rights. Neither has a native iOS or Android app; both run in the browser and can be installed as a PWA.
| Feature | Nastia AI | Candy AI |
|---|---|---|
| Free plan | Daily token limits, no card required | 5 messages total, 1 character, 1 image |
| Cheapest paid | $11.99/month basic | $3.99/month billed yearly |
| Top plan | $15.99/month Unlimited | Premium Plus, price not listed publicly |
| Images | Stylized, 10 tokens, 30โ60 seconds | Photorealistic, about 4 tokens each |
| Video | 1080p on Unlimited, added 2025, short and uneven | Image-to-video, about 12 tokens, no text-to-video |
| Voice | Voice messages, custom voice cloning | Voice messages, beta voice calls about 3 tokens/minute |
| Group chat | Up to 10 companions | Not documented |
| Custom characters | Multiple companions on Unlimited | About 10 tokens; free allows one |
| Language support | Not published | Interface in 13 languages |
Nastia lets you build multiple companions and put them in a group chat of up to 10. That is unusual in this category and useful if you want a scene with several characters rather than a one-on-one chat. The Unlimited plan also includes custom voice cloning, which is a bigger differentiator than it sounds: most rivals stop at canned voice messages.
Candy's custom character costs about 10 tokens, and the free tier allows one. Candy Premium Plus adds personas and 20 memory slots, plus chat clones. If you want a cast of characters with distinct backstories, Candy's memory slots are the more structured tool, but the price is not publicly listed.
If character depth matters more than visuals, Secrets AI uses editable Lorebooks and starts at $19.99/month. It is a different budget.
This is where both platforms quietly fail, and where the marketing gets loudest.
Nastia advertises persistent memory. Reviewers are less impressed. One says it retains 50+ recent messages; another reports up to about two weeks. A published recall test found a detail remembered on day four and gone by day seven. So plan for days, not months.
Candy storylines reportedly reset after 48 to 72 hours. Rivals Bonza.Chat and Kalon claim Candy memory fades after 10โ15 messages. Those are competitor claims, so treat them with suspicion, but the direction matches user reports.
Practical fix on either platform: put key facts in the character's backstory or memory slots, not in chat history. Candy's Premium Plus memory slots exist for this reason. Nastia's group chat helps by keeping context inside a scene rather than across weeks.
If long-term memory is your main requirement, neither of these is the right tool. Our guide to the best AI girlfriend apps by cost and memory covers platforms that prioritize recall, and Nastia's own comparison page notes that Nomi AI runs three memory layers.
Candy wins this section, and it is not close.
Candy's images are photorealistic. Its image-to-video conversion costs about 12 tokens, and Live Action mode pushes results further toward realism. There is no text-to-video, so you start from an image. Voice messages are included, and beta voice calls run about 3 tokens per minute.
Nastia's images are stylized and take 30โ60 seconds for 10 tokens. Video arrived in 2025 and is 1080p on Unlimited, but clips are short and uneven. Voice messages and custom voice cloning are included on Unlimited. The trade is control and price against realism.
If you want the best pictures, Candy is the pick. If you want a voice that sounds like a character you built, Nastia's cloning is the rarer feature.
Here is where the cheap headline prices need a second look. Both platforms meter media with tokens. A low monthly price buys messages, not a free run of the image generator.
| Plan | Price | Features |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | 5 messages total, 1 character, 1 image |
| Premium monthly | $13.99/month | Unlimited messages, 18+ images/video, 100 tokens monthly |
| Premium 3 months | $8.99/month ($26.97) | Same, 100 tokens monthly |
| Premium 12 months | $3.99/month ($47.88) | Same, 100 tokens monthly |
| Premium Plus | Not listed publicly | 330 tokens, personas, 20 memory slots, chat clones |
Candy's yearly plan at $3.99/month is the cheapest entry in this comparison. It is also where the token meter bites hardest. At about 4 tokens per image, 100 tokens is roughly 25 images a month before you buy more. Older sources say 2 tokens per image, which would double that; either way, heavy users run out. Token top-ups are reported from $9.99 per 100 tokens. Reviewers say media-heavy Candy users pay $25 to $80 a month.
Refunds are narrow: within 24 hours, 20 tokens or fewer, card payments only. EU and UK users get a prorated 14-day withdrawal right. Payments accepted include card, Apple Pay, Google Pay, bank transfer and crypto.
| Plan | Price | Features |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0 | Chat with daily token limits, no card needed |
| Basic/Standard | $11.99/month | Listed by Nastia, contents not described anywhere we found |
| Unlimited | $15.99/month | Unlimited messages, 4K selfies, voice messages, 1080p video, multiple companions, voice cloning |
Nastia claims flat pricing, no hidden fees and no token traps. That is only true for messages. The Unlimited plan still meters images and voice notes with tokens. Reviewers report about 3,000 bonus tokens monthly on Unlimited and annual billing from about $8.33/month, though the $11.99 plan's contents are not described anywhere we could find. Token packs are reported at 500 for $3.99.
Nastia's own comparison page claims Candy costs $30โ50/month with fees, $0.20 per image and $0.30 per call minute. Check the math: at $9.99 per 100 tokens, 3 tokens per minute is about $0.30, so the call figure roughly holds. But 4 tokens per image is closer to $0.40, not $0.20. Vendor comparisons deserve a calculator.
Nastia's terms say subscriptions auto-renew and are generally non-refundable. Cancel before you request deletion; the policy says deletion is immediate but requires the subscription to be canceled first.
Nastia wins this one. Its free page says free forever, no lockout, no card needed. The card on the same page lists daily token limits, so the wording contradicts itself. Reviewers report about 40 free daily tokens.
Candy's free tier is a demo: 5 messages total, one character, one image. You will know within ten minutes whether you like it. You will also be out of messages.
Nastia also says uncensored chat is free, but at least one review found no NSFW content on the free tier. Treat the free plan as a trial of the chat engine, not a full product.
Both platforms allow adult content with limits. Candy bans content resembling minors and reports CSAM to NCMEC. Nastia's terms ban minors, aged-up characters and non-consensual content. Neither is a free-for-all, and both enforce.
What differs is enforcement visibility. Candy's policy is more explicit about reporting to authorities. Nastia's terms are stricter on aged-up characters, which closes a loophole some platforms leave open.
Neither platform offers end-to-end encryption. Assume your chats are stored and can be reviewed.
Candy encrypts in transit with TLS 1.2+ and may use de-identified prompts to train models, with some human review. It shares content with third-party model providers and moderation vendors. Account data is kept up to three years after last activity. Charges show as an EverAI billing descriptor.
Nastia's privacy policy was updated September 16, 2026. It says Nastia does not sell personal data, and lists US-based cloud, AI, payment, analytics and advertising processors. The policy does not explicitly mention model training. Deletion is immediate once you cancel the subscription, but rule-violation records are kept up to seven years.
Basic hygiene on either: use a separate email, never share your real name, address or photos of real people, and do not assume a deleted chat is gone. Reviewers also flag emotional dependence and loneliness risks; if the app is replacing human contact rather than supplementing it, that is worth noticing.
Pick Nastia if you mostly type. You want a companion to talk to daily, you like roleplay with several characters, and you want a free tier that does not expire after five messages. Accept stylized images and a token meter on media.
Pick Candy if you mostly look. You want the most realistic images, short video from a still, and voice calls. Accept 100 tokens a month, top-ups, and a 24-hour refund window.
If you are leaving Candy over shallow chat or token costs, Nastia is a reasonable landing spot. If you are leaving Nastia because the pictures look like cartoons, Candy will not disappoint you on visuals but will on memory.
For a direct visual comparison, our CrushOn AI vs Candy AI guide covers text roleplay against photoreal companions, and Candy AI vs OurDream AI looks at which subscription earns its keep.
If neither fits, these are the platforms that come up in the same conversations.
For a wider ranking by price and memory, see our best AI girlfriend apps guide.
Nastia AI is the better conversation platform with the more usable free tier. Candy AI is the better visual platform with the cheaper yearly base but the more punishing token economy. Neither wins on memory or privacy.
Start monthly, on either. Watch your token burn for a week before you commit to a year. And put the facts you care about in the character setup, because the chat history will not hold them.
It depends on what you use it for. Nastia is better for ongoing chat, roleplay and price, while Candy is better for photorealistic images, video and voice calls. Neither is clearly better overall.
Candy's yearly plan at $3.99/month is the cheapest base price, but 100 monthly tokens run out fast for media-heavy users. Nastia's $15.99 Unlimited plan is better value if you mostly chat.
Yes if you are leaving Candy over shallow chat or token costs. No if you want better visuals, because Nastia's images are stylized rather than photorealistic.
It is a Maltese company with discreet billing, but there is no end-to-end encryption and de-identified chats may be used for model training with some human review. Use a separate email and never share real personal details.
No. Neither has a native iOS or Android app, but both work in a browser and can be installed as a PWA.
No. Unlimited means unlimited messages; images and voice notes still use tokens, and the free plan has daily token limits. Nastia's own free-tier page contradicts itself on this point.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls