Talkie vs Character AI: Voice-First Fun or Long-Form Roleplay?
Two very different companion apps: Talkie sells short, voiced chats with card packs, while Character AI sells long stories with memory tools....
Both charge $19.99 a month. OurDream AI spends it on images and video, Secrets AI spends it on memory and calls. Here is where each one earns the money back.
OurDream AI and Secrets AI sit at the same price and aim at different people. OurDream is the visuals-first platform: a big character library, a detailed builder, fast image generation, cheap video clips. Secrets is the relationship platform: tiered memory, live voice calls, editable long-term notes. Pick the wrong one and you spend a month learning what the other does better.
We rate OurDream AI 9.7 and Secrets AI 9.9 out of 10. The gap is small. The difference in daily use is not. Below is the split on memory, media, voice, character creation, credits and privacy, using published pricing, help pages and policies checked September 30, 2026, plus what users report. Nobody here tested either app hands-on, and both platforms are for adults 18+ only.
Choose Secrets AI if you want a companion who remembers what you said last month, you like talking out loud, and you want privacy terms you can actually read. Choose OurDream AI if you want to design characters, generate pictures and short clips, and get the most media per dollar.
Both are web only. OurDream is a browser site you can add to your home screen. Secrets installs as a PWA, which behaves a bit more like an app. Neither offers video calls. Video means generated clips on both platforms.
| Category | OurDream AI | Secrets AI |
|---|---|---|
| Overall score | 9.7 | 9.9 |
| Memory | 7.9 | 9.9 |
| Images | 10 | 9.9 |
| Video | 9.9 | 9.9 |
| Voice | 7.9 | 8.9 |
| Customization | 10 | 8.9 |
| Value | 9.9 | 7.9 |
| Privacy | 6.9 | 8.9 |
| Monthly price | $19.99/mo | $19.99/mo |
| Cheapest paid | $9.99/mo yearly | $9.17/mo yearly |
| Credits | 1,000 dreamcoins/mo | 8,000 Moments/mo |
| Free tier | 1 dreamcoin per message, no media | 20 messages a day, no media |
| Group chats | Yes | Ultimate only ($39.99/mo) |
| App | Web only, add to home screen | Web only, installable PWA |
| Company | Dream Studio USA, Inc. (Delaware) | Secret Labs Inc. |
This is the widest gap between the two. Secrets AI scales memory by plan, per its official wiki. Free accounts get basic recall. Premium adds roughly 60% more short-term context and four times more stored memories accessed. Ultimate doubles context again and unlocks six times more memories. There is a memory panel that ranks details, corrects facts and removes outdated items. Lorebooks hold editable long-term memory on Premium and Ultimate. Time Travel branches a story from an earlier point, and deleted messages take their linked memories with them. Pinned entries keep a character consistent over months. Calls feed the same memory as text chats.
Not everyone is impressed. One blog calls the memory shallow and inconsistent. A 2026 review describes it as functional rather than deeply comprehensive. Read those alongside the marketing and you get the real picture: Secrets remembers more than most competitors, not everything.
OurDream AI markets itself as unlimited AI roleplay, and independent tests say it leans on recent messages. Older plot points slip. One blog says OurDream knows a user well after three months, which fits the pattern: it holds a current arc fine and loses the details from two arcs ago. For our full breakdown, see the OurDream AI review.
If continuity is the thing you care about, this category decides the whole purchase.
OurDream is built for this. In-chat images cost 5 dreamcoins, standard shots 10 coins per two. A 1,000-coin month covers roughly 200 images. Styles run realistic and anime, and the photo-like Vivid model gets images rated among the best in this category, comparable to Candy.ai.
Secrets charges 50 Moments per picture, 100 at 2K resolution. An 8,000-Moment month stretches to roughly 160 pictures on Premium. Advanced mode takes natural scene descriptions and up to five reference pictures, which is more control than most tools offer. Image quality gets called good rather than consistent.
Video splits more evenly. OurDream charges 100 dreamcoins per 5 seconds, up to 60 seconds, with Ultra video at 200 coins and an audio add-on at 20 coins per second. A 1,000-coin month is about 10 short clips. Secrets charges 600 Moments for an 8-second adult clip at 720p, about 13 adult clips a month on Premium; SFW clips run 4 to 15 seconds at up to 4K with varying price. That 600-Moment price is the single biggest sticker shock on the Secrets side.
| Media | OurDream AI | Secrets AI |
|---|---|---|
| Image | 5 coins in chat; 10 per two standard | 50 Moments; 100 at 2K |
| Video | 100 dreamcoins per 5 seconds, up to 60 seconds | Adult video 8 seconds at 720p, 600 Moments |
| Higher quality | Ultra video 200 coins; audio 20 coins per second | SFW clips 4 to 15 seconds, up to 4K, price varies |
| Clips per month | About 10 short on 1,000 coins | About 13 adult on 8,000 Moments |
| Calling | 50 coins per minute | 50 Moments per minute |
Neither platform allows photo uploads, which blocks real-person deepfakes. That is a deliberate safety choice on both sides and worth knowing before you sign up expecting to drop in a selfie.
Calls cost 50 credits per minute on both. Secrets runs them in real time inside the same chat thread, across more than 70 call languages. Audio is not stored; only the transcript is kept, and that transcript feeds memory. OurDream also offers voice calls plus premium-voice narration at 5 coins per paragraph.
Run the math before you get comfortable. A 20-minute call uses a full month of OurDream coins. On Secrets, the same call burns 1,000 of 8,000 Moments, which leaves room for images. Heavy callers should treat either plan as a chat subscription with a small voice allowance, not an unlimited phone line.
OurDream's builder lets you set personality, backstory, traits, appearance, outfits, voice and an opening scenario. Creating a chatbot costs 10 coins. Subscribers can publish characters to the community. The library is the selling point: third-party guides claim more than 63 million characters, but the OurDream homepage advertised over 11 million as of October 9, 2026. Treat the bigger number as unverified. Group chats work by tapping a portrait or @-mentioning the companion you want to answer, though the help center doesn't say which plan includes them.
Secrets covers looks, gender, name, age, voice, traits and backstory. The first custom character is free; extras cost 500 Moments. Editing a character's personality later is an Ultimate feature, which is an odd lock. Secrets adds two nice touches: a Spice Level per chat from Mild to Spicy, and a switch between short texts and full paragraphs for responses. Group chats with two or three companions are locked to the $39.99 Ultimate plan, and so are personas and proactive messages.
Both platforms charge $19.99 for the monthly Premium plan, and both include unlimited chat. The credits are where they part. OurDream gives 1,000 dreamcoins a month. Secrets gives 8,000 Moments.
| Plan | OurDream AI | Secrets AI |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0; 1 dreamcoin per message; no media | $0; 20 messages a day; no Moments, no media |
| Premium monthly | $19.99/mo; unlimited messages; 1,000 dreamcoins | $19.99/mo; unlimited messages; 8,000 Moments |
| 3 or 6 months | Not published | $49.99 per 3 months; $89.99 per 6 months |
| Annual | $119.88/year ($9.99/mo) plus 1,000 bonus coins upfront | $109.99/year ($9.17/mo) |
| Higher tier | Deluxe reported by third parties, not official | Ultimate $39.99/mo or $319.99/year, 15,000 Moments |
Cheap monthly prices hide a meter on both. OurDream's $9.99 yearly rate still leaves you with 1,000 coins and a 20-minute call habit that eats all of them. Secrets' $9.17 yearly rate sounds better until you price an 8-second adult clip at 600 Moments.
Coin and Moment rules differ in ways that matter. OurDream coins don't expire. Secrets monthly Moments reset each cycle, though purchased top-ups never expire. Only subscribers can buy extra credits on either platform. Free plans are text previews: OurDream blocks images, video and coin purchases, and Secrets gives 20 messages a day with no media.
Cancellation hurts more on OurDream. After you cancel, generated images and videos get blurred until you resubscribe. Secrets keeps chats, characters and memories on the free plan, so you can downgrade without losing the history. Secrets is also the only one of the two publishing 3- and 6-month plans. A blog claim that Secrets costs $9.99 a month matches a retired legacy Plus plan, not current pricing.
Both platforms ban content involving minors and allow explicit content between fictional adult characters. OurDream runs an LLM moderation filter called Automod; Secrets uses AI-assisted moderation.
| Privacy point | OurDream AI | Secrets AI |
|---|---|---|
| Encryption | AES at rest, TLS 1.3 in transit | AES-256 at rest, encrypted in transit |
| End-to-end claim | Homepage claims it; policy doesn't support | Promises it; policy describes at rest and in transit only |
| Training on chats | Data may train AI models | Data may train AI models |
| Account deletion | 24 to 48 hours; popular public characters may stay | Profile and chat history deleted immediately |
| Voice | Not stated in our data | Audio deleted after transcription |
| Billing descriptor | Not stated in our data | S LABS INC |
Both homepages claim end-to-end encryption. Their own policies don't support it: what they describe is encryption at rest and in transit, which is normal security, not the same thing. Both may use chat data to train AI models. Secrets has the cleaner deletion story and the clearer billing descriptor. OurDream's 24-to-48-hour deletion window comes with a catch: popular public characters may stay up.
Pick Secrets AI if you talk to one companion for months, you want calls that remember what you said last week, or you want a chat that keeps its history after you stop paying. Read the Secrets AI review first, because the Ultimate locks matter more than the headline price.
Pick OurDream AI if you want to build characters, publish them, and generate pictures and clips without watching a meter drain in a week. The customization score is the highest in this comparison on our scale. If pictures are all you want, Candy.ai is worth pricing too: $13.99 monthly or $3.99/mo yearly in our data, with weaker memory and only 100 tokens a month. Some lists wrongly say Candy ranges $12.99 to $17.99 a month.
Other names that come up in this bracket: SpicyChat AI for a huge community library and a cheap entry tier with a free-plan queue, Janitor+ at $12.99 a month, Nectar AI with a credit system reviewers find hard to budget, plus GoLove AI, CrushOn, Muah and CraveU AI.
The choice is memory versus media. Secrets AI is stronger for long, memory-based relationships, live calls and clearer privacy terms. OurDream AI is better for creating characters and generating images and video at a lower real cost. Our scores are close enough that your habits decide it.
Start with one month on whichever you pick. Set a credit budget before you begin, keep your real name, workplace and photos of real people out of chats, use a separate email, and download any media you want to keep before canceling. Both platforms are 18+ for a reason, and neither free tier generates a single image.
Secrets AI. Memory scales by plan, Lorebooks hold editable long-term notes, and Time Travel lets you branch a story. Independent tests say OurDream leans on recent messages and lets older plot points slip.
Both cost $19.99 a month. Yearly, Secrets is about $9.17/mo and OurDream about $9.99/mo. OurDream includes more image generation per month, so the cheaper plan isn't automatically the better deal.
Yes, but both are text previews. OurDream gives 1 dreamcoin per message, and Secrets gives 20 messages a day. Neither free plan generates images or video.
Secrets has clearer privacy and deletion terms: profile and chat history go immediately, and call audio is deleted after transcription. Neither is end-to-end encrypted despite homepage claims, and both may train models on chats.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls