Talkie vs Character AI: Voice-First Fun or Long-Form Roleplay?
Two very different companion apps: Talkie sells short, voiced chats with card packs, while Character AI sells long stories with memory tools....
Secrets AI wins on memory, voice and privacy. Candy AI wins on photoreal images and the cheapest sticker price. The catch is what Candy's token meter does to that price.
Two paid companion apps, two different sales pitches. Secrets AI sells continuity: memories that stick, editable lore for your characters, live voice calls. Candy AI sells faces: the best still images in this category, plus the lowest annual price we've seen on a name-brand app.
We haven't tested either one. Our rankings come from published feature lists, pricing pages, privacy policies and what paying users report. That's enough to tell you where each one is strong, where the bill surprises people, and which one fits how you actually use a companion app.
Secrets AI is the better companion. We rate it 9.9 out of 10. Candy AI is the better camera. We rate it 9.8 out of 10.
If you want a character who remembers your job, your ex and the thing you said three weeks ago, pick Secrets. If you mostly want a folder of realistic pictures and you'll watch the token counter, Candy's annual plan is the cheapest way in.
One warning before any of the numbers below: Candy's cheap monthly price hides a token meter. Every image, every call, every video conversion burns tokens from a monthly allowance of 100. That allowance is smaller than it sounds, and unused tokens expire if you cancel.
| Category | Secrets AI | Candy AI | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overall rating | 9.9 | 9.8 | Secrets |
| Long-term memory | 9.9 โ Lorebooks | 7.2 โ resets in 48โ72h | Secrets |
| Image quality | 9.9 | 10 โ same face | Candy |
| Video | 9.9 โ 600 Moments a clip | 9.2 โ image-to-video | Secrets |
| Voice | 8.9 โ live calls | 8.2 โ beta calls | Secrets |
| Customization | 8.9 | 10 | Candy |
| Cheapest paid | $9.17/month annual | $3.99/month annual | Candy |
| Monthly credits | 8,000 Moments | 100 tokens | Secrets |
| Free plan | 20 messages a day | 5 messages total | Secrets |
| Privacy | 8.9 | 7.2 | Secrets |
| Mobile app | Web app only | Web app only | Tie |
Secrets AI is run by Secret Labs Inc., registered in Canada and the US. The interface comes in English, German, Spanish, French and Japanese. It has two paid tiers, Premium and Ultimate, and its credit currency is called Moments. You can read the full breakdown in our Secrets AI review.
Candy AI is run by EverAI Limited, registered in Malta. Third-party sources date its launch to 2023. Competitor guides claim more than 11 million monthly visitors; a public Similarweb view showed roughly 63.7 million visits over three months as of August 2026. The interface supports 13 languages. Premium is the main plan, with a newer Premium Plus tier above it. Our Candy.ai review covers the rest.
Neither has a native iOS or Android app. Both install as browser-based web apps. If you see a store listing using either name, it isn't official.
This is the widest gap between the two, and it's the one that matters most over months rather than days.
Secrets AI stores memories per character. You can view them, rank them, correct them and delete them. Lorebooks add sections for cast, world, relationship, facts and chronicle, so you can write the canon yourself instead of hoping the model holds onto it. The free tier gets basic recall. Premium adds about 60% more short-term context and four times the memories. Ultimate doubles the context and gives six times the memory access.
One caveat: the wiki lists Lorebooks on both Premium and Ultimate, while some pages say Ultimate only. Check the plan page before you upgrade for that feature alone.
Candy AI scores far lower here. Users report that memory resets after roughly 48 to 72 hours. Resetting a chat clears that chat's memory outright. Premium Plus adds 20 memory slots, which helps, but slots aren't the same as a working recall system.
Secrets also gives you a choice of chat models. S3 and X-3 are on all plans, S5 comes with Premium, S4 with Ultimate. Thinking levels are adjustable, and each chat has a Spice Level (Mild, Medium, Spicy) that also applies to calls.
Candy wins images, and it isn't close. The thing users mention most is face consistency: the same character keeps the same face across generations. That's rarer than it should be in this category.
Secrets is no slouch. It offers tag-based prompts or an Advanced mode with scene descriptions, up to five reference pictures and output up to 2K. A standard image costs 50 Moments, 100 at 2K. That puts roughly 160 images inside the 8,000-Moment monthly allowance.
Candy's numbers look cheaper on paper. Testers measured about 4 tokens per image in September 2026, so 100 tokens should cover around 25 images. Here's where the token meter bites: private content packs reportedly run 100 to 400 tokens, which is your entire monthly allowance on one purchase.
Video flips back to Secrets. It does 8-second adult clips at 720p for 600 Moments, which works out to about 13 clips a month on Premium. SFW clips run up to 15 seconds, with the price scaling by resolution and length. Candy does image-to-video for about 12 tokens, with no text-to-video, so 100 tokens cover roughly eight conversions.
One more difference worth knowing. Secrets refunds failed generations automatically. Candy charges per attempt, so a bad roll still costs you.
Secrets offers live voice calls at 50 Moments per minute. You set the call language from more than 70 options. Voice messages cost 10 Moments per 100 characters. Candy's calls are still in beta, at roughly 3 tokens per minute according to testers.
Neither advertises voice cloning. If that's a must-have, look at Nastia, whose top plan offers it.
Candy's builder is the more detailed of the two: ethnicity, age, body type, hair, voice, personality and hobbies, with realistic or anime styles. Free users can create one character. Extra characters cost about 10 tokens according to testers. Premium Plus adds user personas and chat clones.
Secrets asks for gender, look, name, age, voice, traits and backstory. Your first custom character is free; extras cost 500 Moments. Its library holds about 94 prebuilt companions according to guides and one review. Ultimate adds group chat with two or three companions, AI personas, proactive messages and personality editing.
We found no official documentation of group chat on Candy. Don't buy Premium Plus expecting it.
| Plan | Secrets AI | Candy AI |
|---|---|---|
| Free | 20 messages/day, no Moments | 5 messages total, 1 character, 1 image |
| Monthly | Premium $19.99 | Premium $13.99 |
| Quarterly | $49.99 ($16.66/mo) | $26.97 ($8.99/mo) |
| 6 months | $89.99 ($15.00/mo) | Not offered |
| Annual | $109.99 ($9.17/mo) | $47.88 ($3.99/mo) |
| Top tier | Ultimate $39.99/mo or $319.99/yr | Premium Plus, price at checkout only |
| Credits | 8,000 Moments (Ultimate 15,000) | 100 tokens (Premium Plus 330) |
Some older guides still cite Candy at $12.99 a month plus token fees, and Secrets at $19.99 with limited features. The figures above come from the current pricing pages.
Candy's sticker price is genuinely lower. $3.99 a month against $9.17 is not a rounding error. But run the media math. Heavy Candy users report $25 to $80 a month in total once top-ups kick in. Top-ups reportedly start at $9.99 for 100 tokens. At that point the cheap plan is a doorway, not a price.
Secrets' real entry point is $19.99 a month, and adult video at 600 Moments a clip means Premium covers around 13 of them. The best extras โ group chat, personas, 15,000 Moments โ need the $39.99 Ultimate plan.
Credit rules differ too. Secrets' monthly grants don't roll over, but purchased Moments never expire. Candy's unused tokens expire at the end of the billing period if you cancel.
Billing descriptors: Secrets shows up as S LABS INC, Candy as EverAI. Useful if you're scanning a statement.
Secrets gives you 20 messages a day, basic memory and access to all premade companions. No media generation without paying.
Candy gives you 5 messages total, one character, one image and no adult media. That's a demo, not a free tier. It tells you what the interface looks like and nothing about whether the app is worth paying for.
Both platforms are 18+, both allow NSFW content with fictional adult characters, and both ban minors. Both run Discord servers. Those rules are table stakes; the differences are in the policies.
| Point | Secrets AI | Candy AI |
|---|---|---|
| Encryption | AES-256 at rest, encrypted in transit | TLS in transit, encrypted passwords |
| End-to-end | No โ homepage claim is unbacked | No |
| Training on chats | Data may train and improve models | De-identified chats may train models, with human review |
| Deletion | Chat history deleted immediately with account | Account data kept up to 3 years after last activity |
| Voice audio | Deleted after transcription | Not specified |
| Billing descriptor | S LABS INC | EverAI |
Candy is GDPR compliant, and EverAI Limited is the data controller under Maltese law. It also shares message content with third-party LLM providers and moderation vendors. That's normal for the category, but it means your chats travel further than the Candy domain.
Third-party sites claim Candy uses TLS 1.3 and AES-256 at rest. A connection check showed TLS 1.3 in October 2026. Candy's own privacy notice names no at-rest method, so treat the AES-256 claim as unverified. Card data reportedly isn't stored on Candy's servers. Secrets hands card numbers to PCI-DSS processors.
Neither platform publishes an independent security audit or compliance certification that we could find. Secrets' homepage makes an end-to-end encryption claim that nothing in its documentation backs up.
Candy refunds within 24 hours if you've used 20 tokens or fewer, card payments only. Secrets doesn't refund subscriptions or Moments except where law requires, and crypto purchases are never refunded.
EU and UK users get a 14-day withdrawal right on both. If you're in that region, that's your real safety net. If you're not, assume you're keeping what you buy.
Pick Secrets AI if you want a long-running character, you'll use voice calls, or you care what happens to your chat history. Start with annual Premium at $9.17 a month. Go Ultimate only if you need group chat, personas or 15,000 Moments.
Pick Candy AI if realistic images are the main draw and you'll keep an eye on the token counter. Annual Premium at $3.99 is the cheapest way in. If you're a heavy media user, budget for top-ups before you subscribe, not after.
Pick neither if you need a native app. Both are browser-only.
If token systems are the problem, Nomi AI runs $15.99 a month or $99.99 a year with no token system for chat, and has native iOS and Android apps โ claims we haven't verified. OurDream AI takes a different angle: unlimited chat with metered media, covered in our OurDream AI review.
On the cheaper end, CrushOn AI plans start at $5.99 a month, with a Standard tier that's text-focused. Kupid AI claims more than 100 personas, with Premium listed at $13.99 a month. Nastia offers uncensored chat without token fees according to its own pages, plus voice cloning on the top plan. Kalon AI claims flat pricing without hidden costs, and Rabu AI advertises 256-bit encryption; neither claim is confirmed.
Practical habits: use a separate email address, keep real names and photos of real people out of chats, and don't share an account. Sharing mixes memories and history between people, and neither platform advertises multi-user accounts.
Secrets AI is the better companion; Candy AI is the better camera. Start with Secrets Premium if you want a relationship that lasts past the weekend, voice calls and media credits that don't vanish by the 5th of the month. Choose Candy if photoreal images are what you're paying for and you'll watch the meter. Either way, treat this as entertainment, not real support.
Secrets AI, for most people. It wins on memory, voice, media credits, free tier and privacy. Candy AI wins on image quality, customization and the lowest annual price. Pick Candy only if realistic pictures are your main reason for subscribing.
On the sticker price, yes: $3.99 a month annual against $9.17. But Candy gives you 100 tokens a month, and private content packs reportedly cost 100 to 400 tokens. Heavy media users report $25 to $80 a month in total once top-ups are counted.
Secrets AI. It stores memories per character, lets you view, rank, correct and delete them, and adds editable Lorebooks on paid tiers. Candy AI reportedly resets memory after 48 to 72 hours, and resetting a chat clears that chat's memory.
No. Both are browser-based web apps as of 2026. Any app store listing using either name is unofficial, so install from the website if you want it on your home screen.
Secrets AI has the clearer policy: AES-256 at rest, encrypted in transit, and chat history deleted immediately when you close your account. Candy keeps account data up to three years after activity and names no at-rest encryption method. Neither offers end-to-end encryption, and both may use chats to train models.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls