Talkie vs Character AI: Voice-First Fun or Long-Form Roleplay?
Two very different companion apps: Talkie sells short, voiced chats with card packs, while Character AI sells long stories with memory tools....
Secrets AI has good memory and Lorebooks, but the price, missing app, and narrow free tier send people looking. Here's the alternative for each complaint.
You're not leaving Secrets AI because it's bad. You're leaving because one thing bugs you. The alternative you want depends on that one thing. Here's the short list. We go deeper on each below.
| Reason | Pick | Price from |
|---|---|---|
| $19.99 steep for images | OurDream AI | $9.99/month annual |
| Lowest annual price | Candy AI | $3.99/month annual |
| No native app | Nomi, Kindroid | $8.33/month Nomi annual |
| Group chat locked to Ultimate | CrushOn AI | $5.99/month |
| Free tier too narrow | Janitor AI, SpicyChat | Free |
| Appearance control | Nectar AI | $9.99/month |
| Gentler, less explicit | Replika | $5.83/month annual |
If your gripe isn't here, skip to Secrets AI vs Candy AI for a direct comparison, or read our full Secrets AI review to see what you'd be giving up.
Secrets AI scores well in our reviewâ9.9 out of 10âlargely on memory, Lorebooks, and voice calls. But the complaints are consistent. Price is the big one: $19.99 a month, or $109.99 a year (about $9.17/month). That's fair for what you get if you use everything. If you mostly want pictures, it's steep.
Then there's the app. Secrets AI has no App Store or Google Play listing. It's a browser web app only. For people who chat on a phone, that's a dealbreaker.
The free tier is also thin: 20 responses a day, no Moments, no images or videos. You can't really test the media features without paying.
And group chat? Locked behind Ultimate at $39.99 a month. If you want to talk to two or three characters at once, you're paying double.
Finally, billing. Subscriptions are non-refundable except where law requires, and crypto payments are never refunded. Moments don't roll over. People notice.
Here's how the main alternatives compare on price and what you get.
| Platform | Monthly | Best per-month | Media currency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Secrets Premium | $19.99 | $9.17 annual | 8,000 Moments |
| Secrets Ultimate | $39.99 | $26.67 annual | 15,000 Moments |
| OurDream AI | $19.99 | $9.99 annual | 1,000 dreamcoins |
| Candy AI | $13.99 | $3.99 annual | 100 tokens |
| Nomi | $15.99 | $8.33 annual | Credits |
| Kindroid | $15.99 app | $13.33 annual | Selfie and voice credits |
| CrushOn AI | $5.99â$199.99 | Varies | Tier credits |
| Nectar AI | $9.99â$34.99 | About 50% off annual | Credits |
Free access and native apps matter too. Here's the quick version.
| Platform | Free access | Native app |
|---|---|---|
| OurDream AI | 1 dreamcoin per message, no images | No, web |
| Candy AI | 5 messages total | No, web |
| Nomi | Limited messages | iOS and Android |
| Kindroid | 50-message preview | iOS and Android |
| CrushOn AI | 100 credits monthly | Not verified |
| Nectar AI | 15 messages + 10 generations daily | Not verified |
| Janitor AI | Yes | No |
| SpicyChat | Yes, with queue | Android |
| Replika | Friend mode | iOS and Android |
| HeraHaven | Limited | Not listed |
If your complaint is "Secrets costs too much for pictures and video," OurDream AI is the obvious first stop. It's $19.99 monthly or $9.99/month billed $119.88 yearly. That's the same monthly price as Secrets Premium but the annual rate is a bit higher. The difference is what you get.
OurDream includes unlimited chat plus 1,000 dreamcoins monthlyâabout 200 images. Video costs 100 dreamcoins per 5 seconds, up to 60 seconds. Voice calls are 50 coins a minute. Compare that to Secrets: 8,000 Moments, an image costs 50, an 8-second adult video costs 600, and calls are 50 a minute. Do the math: OurDream gives you more images per dollar if that's your thing.
But there are caveats. OurDream's free tier is 1 dreamcoin per message and no image generation. Some guides claim 50 free messages and 5 images dailyâthat's not what the pricing page says. Also, images and videos blur if your subscription lapses. And the homepage claims end-to-end encryption, but the privacy policy says server-side encryption and allows training on your data. That's a contradiction worth knowing.
For a direct head-to-head, see OurDream AI vs Secrets AI.
Candy AI has the cheapest annual plan: $3.99/month, billed $47.88 a year. Monthly is $13.99, quarterly works out to $8.99/month. That's hard to beat if price is your only concern.
But cheap monthly hides a token meter. Candy Premium includes 100 tokens monthly, and an image costs about 4 tokens. Heavy users report spending $25â$80 a month on top-ups. The free plan is just 5 messages totalânot 5 a day, 5 ever.
Refunds are only within 24 hours, card payments only, and you must have used 20 tokens or fewer. Testers report conversations resetting after two or three days. So if memory is why you liked Secrets, Candy might disappoint. Our Candy.ai review has more on that.
Roundups claim Candy video clips up to 120 seconds, but that's unconfirmed. We'd treat it as marketing until you see it in the app.
If your gripe is "Secrets has no app and I want something that remembers," Nomi is a strong pick. It's $15.99 monthly or $99.99 yearlyâabout $8.33/month. It supports up to ten companions per subscription plus group chats, so you don't need the top tier for that.
One review says Nomi allows sharing up to 40 images daily. Credits are sold from $4.99 for 40. Nomi allows explicit text but no nude images. That's a limitation if visuals are your thing, but if you want long conversations that stick, Nomi is built for that.
It has iOS and Android apps. For a phone-first user, that alone might be the reason to switch.
Kindroid is another app-first option. Standard is $15.99/month via app stores, or $13.99 on the website as reported. Annual works out to $13.33/month per the pricing table. The free option is a one-time 50-message preview, then read-only. The 3-day trial requires a payment method.
Kindroid offers voice cloning, real-time voice calls, live video calls, and even iMessage/RCS texts. Voice packs cost 500,000 credits for $14.99. Live Avatar video costs about 2,500 credits a minute on top of the call charge. So the meter is there, but the features are deep.
If you left Secrets because you wanted more voice and video, Kindroid is worth a look. It's not cheap, but it's not Secrets Ultimate either.
Secrets locks group chats behind Ultimate at $39.99/month. CrushOn AI starts at $5.99/month for Standard, with Premium at $14.99 and a top tier at $199.99/month. Free users get 100 message credits monthly plus unlimited free models.
Context is 8K free, up to 24K paid. Free conversation history is deleted after seven days of inactivity. So it's text-first, and you need to stay active to keep your chats.
If group roleplay is your main draw, CrushOn gives you that at a fraction of Secrets Ultimate. But check the features on each tierânot all group features may be in the $5.99 plan.
Nectar AI plans are $9.99, $19.99, and $34.99 monthly, with about 50% off annual. The free tier gives 15 messages and 10 generations daily. Reviewers count 300+ options for customizationâroundups say over 350. That's the selling point: you can shape appearance and behavior.
But reviewers report $60â$75 monthly top-ups at moderate use. Encryption and retention policies are unclear. So if you want deep customization and don't mind the meter, Nectar is an option. If you want transparency, look elsewhere.
If your gripe is "Secrets' free tier is too narrow," Janitor AI and SpicyChat are the free options. Janitor AI is free including its own model; you can use your own API key to unlock other models. Janitor+ is $12.99/month, launched June 2026, and gives about five times the context plus priority. But Janitor has no image, video, voice messages, or calls. It's text only.
SpicyChat tiers are $5.95, $19.95, and $29.95 monthly after a September 2026 price rise. Free chat has no hard daily cap but sometimes a queue. Free and $5.95 replies are capped at 180 tokens. That's shortâyou'll notice repetitive replies. It has an Android app.
Neither will replace Secrets' media features, but for pure text roleplay, they're free or cheap. For more on free options, see the best AI chatbot for roleplay.
Replika is about $5.83/month annually. Replika 2.0 adds voice conversations and real-time video calls per its site. But there's no explicit content, and romantic modes need a paid plan. Italy fined Replika's operator âŹ5 million in 2025. So if you want a companion app that's more emotional support than adult roleplay, Replika fits. If you want what Secrets offers, it won't.
HeraHaven is $19.95 monthly or $6.65/month annually, with 500 Luna tokens monthly. Users report quality degrading after a few hundred messages, and refund terms are unverified. We'd be cautious.
Other names in roundupsâKalon AI, Xotic AI, Cherrypop.aiâmake claims like real-time voice without extra currency, 4K clips up to 15 seconds, or deep character customization. We haven't verified those. Treat them as marketing until you see independent reports. For a broader list, see our AI girlfriend reviews hub.
Monthly prices are straightforward. Annual prices are where the deals areâbut check what you get. Secrets Premium at $9.17/month annual is competitive, but OurDream at $9.99/month annual gives more images. Candy at $3.99/month annual is the cheapest, but tokens add up. Nomi at $8.33/month annual includes ten companions and group chats. Kindroid at $13.33/month annual includes voice and video, but credits cost extra.
Watch for token meters. Secrets gives 8,000 Moments monthly, but they don't roll over. OurDream gives 1,000 dreamcoinsâabout 200 imagesâand video eats 100 coins per 5 seconds. Candy gives 100 tokens, and heavy users pay $25â$80 extra. None of these are unlimited.
Secrets' strength is memory and Lorebooksâeditable lore that keeps the story consistent. Nomi and Kindroid are built for long history, but neither has Secrets' editable Lorebooks. Candy testers report conversation resetting after two or three days. CrushOn deletes free history after seven days of inactivity. Janitor AI's context depends on the model you use; Janitor+ gives about five times the context. SpicyChat's 180-token cap on cheap tiers makes replies repetitive.
If memory is your priority, Secrets is still strong. Nomi is the closest alternative.
Secrets: image 50 Moments, 8-second adult video 600 Moments, voice call 50/minute. OurDream: image about 5 dreamcoins? Actually 1,000 dreamcoins â 200 images, so 5 coins per image. Video 100 coins per 5 seconds, up to 60 seconds. Voice 50 coins/minute. Candy: 100 tokens monthly, image about 4 tokens. Video up to 120 seconds unconfirmed. Nomi: no nude images, but up to 40 images daily per one review. Kindroid: voice cloning, real-time calls, live video calls, but Live Avatar costs about 2,500 credits/minute. CrushOn: text-first, no media mentioned. Nectar: images and generations, 10 free daily. Janitor: no images, video, or voice. SpicyChat: no media mentioned. Replika: voice and video calls in 2.0, no explicit content.
So if you want adult visuals, Secrets and OurDream are the main options. OurDream gives more images per dollar. Candy is cheaper but tokens run out fast.
Secrets has Lorebooks and per-chat Spice Level and Time Travel branching. That's deep. Nomi allows ten companions and group chats. Kindroid offers voice cloning and real-time calls. CrushOn has group chat on lower tiers. Nectar has 300+ customization options. Janitor AI lets you use your own API key for different models. SpicyChat has a character builder but cheap tiers are limited. Replika is more about one companion.
If you want group roleplay, CrushOn or Nomi. If you want deep lore, Secrets. If you want customization, Nectar.
No platform in this list offers true end-to-end encryption. Secrets uses AES-256 at rest, deletes history on account deletion, doesn't store voice audio, but data may train models. OurDream claims end-to-end encryption but policy says server-side and allows training. Candy's policy is unclear. Nomi's policy is unclear. Kindroid's policy is unclear. CrushOn's policy is unclear. Nectar's policy is unclear. Janitor's policy is unclear. SpicyChat's policy is unclear. Replika has faced regulatory action. HeraHaven's refund terms are unverified.
Also, the 2024 Muah.ai breach exposed about 1.9 million email addresses and prompts. That's a reminder to use a unique password and consider what you share.
Start with your gripe. If it's price for images, go OurDream. If it's the lowest annual price, go Candy, but watch tokens. If it's no app, go Nomi or Kindroid. If it's group chat, go CrushOn. If it's free access, go Janitor or SpicyChat. If it's customization, go Nectar. If it's a gentler tone, go Replika.
If your gripe is memory, Secrets is still one of the best. You might not find a better alternativeâjust different trade-offs.
Secrets AI is hard to beat if you use Lorebooks, voice calls, and want adult images and video in one place. The annual Premium at $9.17/month is reasonable. But if you're paying $19.99 monthly and only using images, you're overpaying. If you need a native app, you're out of luck. If you want group chat, Ultimate is expensive.
So stay if memory and lore are your priority and you're on annual. Leave if any of the gripes above are dealbreakers.
Match the alternative to your reason for leaving. OurDream for cheaper visuals, Candy for lowest annual price, Nomi or Kindroid for native apps, CrushOn for cheap group chat, Nectar for customization, Janitor or SpicyChat for free text. Otherwise, Secrets remains hard to beat. For more options, see our best AI girlfriend apps guide.
For most people, OurDream AI is the closest match: similar features, more images and videos per dollar. If memory and a native app matter more, Nomi is the pick.
Janitor AI and SpicyChat are free for text roleplay. No free option includes images, adult video, or voice calls. Candy, CrushOn, and Nectar have limited free tiers, but they run out fast.
No. Secrets AI is a browser web app only. Nomi, Kindroid, and Replika have native apps for iOS and Android.
Nomi and Kindroid are built for long conversation history. Neither has Secrets' editable Lorebooks, so if that feature is important, Secrets is still the stronger choice.
Yes. Secrets Premium is $109.99 a year, about $9.17/month, compared to $19.99 monthly. But check if the annual plan includes the same Moments and features.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls