Talkie vs Character AI: Voice-First Fun or Long-Form Roleplay?
Two very different companion apps: Talkie sells short, voiced chats with card packs, while Character AI sells long stories with memory tools....
Two adult companion apps with very different priorities. Secrets AI sells continuity, live calls and realistic media. Nastia AI sells cheap monthly chat and big group scenes. Here is how to tell which one you actually want.
Secrets AI and Nastia AI both bill themselves as adult AI companions. They are not the same product wearing different colors. Secrets AI is built around remembering you, calling you and generating realistic photos and video. Nastia AI is built around cheap monthly chat, quick flirting and crowded group scenes.
That difference shows up in the price, the memory, the voice features and the privacy paperwork. Below is what the published pages and user reports actually say, with the catches left in.
We rate Secrets AI 9.9 out of 10 and Nastia AI 9.4 out of 10. The short version: Secrets is the more complete product and costs more for it. Nastia is the budget pick, and its memory is the thing most likely to let you down.
Pick Secrets AI if you want a companion that remembers details from weeks ago, takes live voice calls and produces realistic images and adult video. Expect $19.99/month, and expect the best features to sit on the $39.99 Ultimate tier.
Pick Nastia AI if you want to spend $11.99/month, chat with up to ten companions in one room, and don't need calls or studio-grade media. Expect the memory to fade after several days.
Secrets AI is run by Secret Labs Inc., listed in the US/Canada, and is adults-only. Its pitch is the long relationship: tiered memory, Lorebooks you can edit, live calls in 70+ languages, and a Spice Level setting per chat instead of one global toggle.
Nastia AI is run by Nastia Cybernetics, a French company. Its pitch is volume and price: cheap plans, uncensored chat by default according to the vendor, group chats up to ten companions, and personality traits built around the seven deadly sins.
Neither one is a phone app. Both run in a browser plus an installable web app. If you see a listing in an app store, it isn't official.
| Feature | Secrets AI | Nastia AI | Edge |
|---|---|---|---|
| Best for | Long relationships, continuity, calls | Casual flirting, budget, groups | Depends |
| Paid entry | $19.99/mo ($9.17 yearly) | $11.99/mo | Nastia |
| Top plan | $39.99/mo Ultimate | $15.99/mo Unlimited | Nastia |
| Free tier | 20 daily messages, media locked | Daily token limits | Tie |
| Memory | Tiered memory, Lorebooks | Claimed persistent; reviewers see drop-off | Secrets |
| Voice | Live calls plus TTS | Voice messages, cloning, no live calls found | Secrets |
| Images/video | Realistic photos, adult video | Images, selfies, short video on Unlimited | Secrets |
| Group chats | 2-3, Ultimate only | Up to 10 | Nastia |
| Content controls | Per-chat Spice Level | Uncensored default, rule limits | Tie |
| Apps | Browser plus web app | Browser plus web app | Tie |
| Privacy | AES-256 at rest, no call audio | Encryption in transit only | Secrets |
Secrets does adult content, but it gives you a dial rather than a switch. Each chat gets a Spice Level: Mild, Medium or Spicy. That is more control than most apps offer, and it means one companion can stay tame while another doesn't.
What Secrets won't do is anything involving minors. The policy bans it outright, including so-called aged-up depictions, and the platform uses AI-assisted moderation to catch underage signals. That is the right line, and it is worth knowing it is enforced.
Nastia markets itself as uncensored, and its terms ban the same hard limits: minors including aged-up versions, non-consent and impersonating real people. One review found no NSFW content on the free plan despite the uncensored wording, which fits a pattern of plan descriptions that don't match what you get.
This is the biggest gap between the two, and the one that decides whether a companion feels like a person or a stranger every Monday.
Secrets tiers memory by plan. The free tier gets basic memory, and details fade. Paid plans get the fuller system, plus Lorebooks on Premium and Ultimate, where you can edit memory sections directly. Most reviews and the wiki agree that paid conversations don't reset between sessions.
That matters because editing memory by hand is the difference between hoping the model remembers your job and writing it down where it can't miss it.
Nastia says it has persistent memory and that "nothing resets." Reviewers describe something shorter: recall over roughly 50+ messages, stretching to about two weeks at best. One test put a specific detail in front of the companion. It survived to day four. By day seven, it was gone.
The practical workaround is to put what matters in the backstory, which users report holds up to about 2,000 characters, rather than trusting the chat history. Treat Nastia's memory as a short conversation, not a relationship file.
Secrets runs on four chat models: S3 and X-3 on every plan, S5 from Premium up, and S4 on Ultimate only. Media costs credits from a Moments allowance: 8,000 per month on Premium, 15,000 on Ultimate. An image is 50 credits, a 2K image is 100, and an adult video is 600. Live calls run 50 credits per minute across 70+ call languages, and text-to-speech is 10 credits per 100 characters.
Two catches. First, monthly credit grants do not roll over, so unused Moments vanish. Second, video burns through credits fast; a handful of clips can eat a meaningful chunk of the month. The good news is that failed image generations are refunded automatically.
Nastia is simpler and cheaper per item. Users report images at about 10 tokens each, taking 30-60 seconds, with reference photos supported. Voice messages reportedly cost one token each, and the Unlimited plan includes custom voice cloning. The Unlimited plan also lists 4K selfies and 1080p video.
What Nastia doesn't have, as far as we can find, is live voice calls. Voice notes and cloning are not the same as picking up the phone. If calls are the point for you, that decides it.
Secrets gives you one custom character free, then charges 500 credits for extras. Group chats exist but are capped at two or three companions and locked to the Ultimate plan. The Spice Level and Lorebooks sit alongside creation, so you can tune tone and memory per character.
Nastia is the opposite shape. Backstories are reported up to about 2,000 characters, traits are themed around the seven deadly sins, and group chats hold up to ten companions on paid plans. If your idea of a good evening is a crowded room with several personalities in it, Nastia is built for that and Secrets barely tries.
| Plan | Secrets AI | Nastia AI |
|---|---|---|
| Free | $0: 20 daily messages, basic memory, media locked | Free, daily token limits, no card |
| Entry paid | Premium $19.99/mo | $11.99/mo, contents not described |
| Multi-month | $49.99/3mo; $89.99/6mo | Annual billing reported |
| Annual | $109.99/yr (~$9.17/mo) | Reported $87.95 Basic, $99.95 Unlimited |
| Top tier | Ultimate $39.99/mo, $319.99/yr | Unlimited $15.99/mo |
| Media currency | Moments 8,000 Premium, 15,000 Ultimate | Tokens; 3,000 bonus reported on Unlimited |
Read the Secrets column carefully. The $9.17/month figure is the annual price divided by twelve, and it requires paying $109.99 up front. Monthly, you are at $19.99. Groups and the S4 model need Ultimate at $39.99. And the Moments meter sits on top of all of it: a cheap-looking monthly rate still hides a credit system that video drains quickly.
Nastia is cheaper at every tier. The top plan, Unlimited at $15.99/month, undercuts Secrets' entry plan. An older $6.69 tier shows up on one third-party listing and plan names shift between pages and reviews, so confirm what you're buying before you pay. Nastia's refund policy is generally non-refundable, and it auto-renews.
Secrets is also non-refundable except where the law requires otherwise, though EU and UK buyers keep a 14-day right to cancel.
Secrets gives you 20 messages a day, basic memory, and the S3 and X-3 models. Messages cap at 500 characters. Media is locked, so free is text only. It is enough to judge the writing style, not enough to judge the pictures.
Nastia's free plan runs on daily token limits and doesn't require a card. The wording around what is and isn't included is contradictory, and at least one review found no NSFW content on free despite the uncensored pitch. Go in expecting limits.
The sensible test: build the same character on both free tiers, tell it three specific facts about you, and come back in a week. Secrets should still know them on a paid plan. Nastia likely won't.
| Topic | Secrets AI | Nastia AI |
|---|---|---|
| Company | Secret Labs Inc. (US/Canada) | Nastia Cybernetics (France) |
| Encryption | AES-256 at rest and transit, not E2E | In transit only |
| Training | Policy allows training | Not explicit; used to improve replies |
| Voice data | Call audio deleted, transcript kept | Voice samples collected |
| Selling data | Card numbers not stored (PCI) | Says never sells data |
| Deletion | Chats immediate; 7-year transaction records | Immediate after cancel; violations up to 7 years |
| Refunds | Non-refundable except law; EU/UK 14-day | Generally non-refundable; auto-renews |
Secrets has the stronger encryption story: AES-256 at rest and in transit, and call audio is deleted after the call, with only the transcript kept for memory. But it is not end-to-end encrypted, and the homepage's end-to-end claim is contradicted by its own privacy policy. The policy also allows using your data for model training. Chat history is deleted immediately on request, though transaction records stay for seven years.
Nastia encrypts in transit only, according to its policy, and collects voice samples. It says it never sells data, which is worth something, but some of its vendors are US-based. Deletion is immediate, but you have to cancel before deleting your account, and violation records can be held for up to seven years.
Age checks differ too. Secrets relies on self-attestation and may ask for extra verification. Nastia uses a third-party age confirmation provider. Neither is end-to-end encrypted, so treat both as services that can read your chats.
One claim floating around, that Secrets sign-up works without an email, isn't confirmed by the wiki. Don't count on it.
Secrets AI: the real cost is $19.99/month, and the features people talk about most, groups and the S4 model, need the $39.99 Ultimate tier. Video drains credits fast. Payments are generally non-refundable. The pile of models and settings is confusing at first.
Nastia AI: memory fades after several days, so long relationships don't hold. Free-plan wording contradicts itself. There are no live calls, and images and clips trail the leaders. Plan names change between pages. Put key facts in the backstory, not the chat.
For a fuller picture of how Secrets stacks up against the big names, our full Secrets AI review and the Secrets AI vs Candy AI comparison go deeper on where the money goes.
| App | Best match for | Pricing (reported) |
|---|---|---|
| Candy AI | Photorealistic images, visual builder | $13.99/mo or $3.99/mo yearly |
| Nomi | Long-term memory | $15.99/mo |
| Kindroid | Memory, calls, live video | $15.99/mo (App Store) |
| GoLove AI | Voice and in-chat photos | ~$4.15/mo per guide; our data $9.99 |
| CraveU AI | Budget pricing | From $4.99/mo annual (reported) |
| Muah AI | Cheap annual VIP | ~$5.83/mo ($69.99/yr) |
| Botify AI | Mobile app, casual roleplay | $19.99/mo (reported) |
If memory is what you're chasing, Nomi describes a three-layer memory system and Kindroid describes five layers with live avatar calls, both at $15.99/month. Nomi doesn't allow nude images, so know that going in. If you want pictures, Candy is the obvious stop; our Candy.ai review covers the trade-off between great images and thin memory. If price is the whole point, Muah is the cheapest annual VIP here, but a 2024 breach exposed user emails and prompts, so weigh that. OurDream AI is another option if unlimited chat matters more than media, covered in our OurDream AI vs Secrets AI breakdown.
Some of these prices are unverified and provisional. Check the pricing page before you pay, and avoid fake app listings, since none of these have official store apps.
For the wider field, see our ranked list of AI girlfriend apps by cost and memory.
Secrets AI is the more complete companion: real memory, live calls, realistic media, and privacy terms that are stronger than most. You pay for it, and the credit meter keeps running after the subscription starts.
Nastia AI is the budget fling: cheap, uncensored by default, generous with group scenes, and forgetful after a week. That's not a flaw if you want a fling. It's a problem if you wanted a relationship.
Test both free tiers with the same character and the same three facts about yourself. A week later, you'll know which one you're actually paying for. Keep fantasies fictional, use a spare email, don't share real names, addresses or photos, and take a break if the chats start replacing people rather than adding to them.
Secrets AI is better for long-term memory, live voice calls and realistic media. Nastia AI is better if you want cheap uncensored chat and large group roleplay. They're aimed at different buyers.
Nastia AI, clearly. Its top plan is $15.99/month, while Secrets starts at $19.99/month. Secrets' annual plan works out to about $9.17/month, which narrows the gap but requires paying $109.99 up front.
Not on paid plans, according to the wiki and most reviews. The free tier gets basic memory and details fade. Paid plans add Lorebooks, where you can edit memory sections directly.
We found recorded voice notes and voice cloning, but no live calls. Secrets AI does offer live calls, priced at 50 credits per minute across 70+ call languages.
Secrets has the stronger terms: AES-256 encryption at rest and in transit, and call audio is deleted while only the transcript is kept. Nastia encrypts in transit only and collects voice samples. Neither is end-to-end encrypted, and Secrets' policy allows model training.
Realistic AI companions with strong memory, video and voice calls